26/04 - 20:00
 | The referee whistles for the end of the match | |
| 85' |  | NY Red Bulls: Derrick Etienne Jr.(in) - Alex Muyl(out) |
| 85' | | NY Red Bulls: Marc Rzatkowski (in) - Alex Muyl(out) |
| 84' | | Columbus Crew: Luis Argudo(in) - Justin Meram(out) |
| 82' | | Columbus Crew: Cristian Martínez(in) - Pedro Santos(out) |
| 79' | | Columbus Crew: Patrick Mullins(in) - Gastón Sauro(out) |
| 76' |  | GOAL NY Red Bulls: Daniel Royer (NY Red Bulls) scores! |
| 73' | | GOAL NY Red Bulls: Daniel Royer (NY Red Bulls) scores! |
 | 2nd half begins | |
 | The 1st half ends | |
| 17' | | GOAL NY Red Bulls: Alex Muyl (NY Red Bulls) scores! |
 | The match begins | |
